The silence around dying

Dr Nelia Drenth explores how family efforts to protect their loved one can affect how they cope and create silence around dying.

You can listen to this article below, or by using your favourite podcast player at pod.link/oncologybuddies

There is a land of the living and a land of the dead, and the bridge is love, the only survival, the only meaning. ~ Thornton Wilder

There is a particular kind of silence that often enters a family when someone is facing a life-limiting illness. It’s not the quiet of peace or acceptance. It’s a careful, watchful silence, filled with half-truths, changed subjects, forced optimism, and unspoken fears. 

This silence is usually born out of love. Families want to protect the person who is ill from pain, despair, or giving up. And quite often the patient is silent for the same reasons as the family. Yet, unintentionally, this protection can make the journey lonelier and heavier for both the patient and the family where everybody tries to shield each other. 

Why families go quiet

Families often believe that talking openly about dying will take away hope, increase fear of upsetting the patient, and cause them to lose motivation to live while dying. There is constant conflict between holding on and letting go. Grief becomes a silent partner from the moment of the diagnosis of a life-threatening illness and continuous after death. 

In many cultures, including here in South Africa, death is a difficult topic, sometimes taboo, sometimes surrounded by strong beliefs about positivity, faith, or resilience. Silence becomes a way of coping. If you don’t name it, perhaps it won’t happen. Moreover, this state makes it difficult to deal with imminent death as it obstructs saying farewell in time, heal broken relationships, and making necessary arrangements. 

But illness has a way of speaking its own truth. The body knows. The person who is ill often knows more than families realise. 

What the person who is ill may experience

When conversations about dying are avoided, patients frequently describe a deep sense of isolation. They may think that they must protect their family from their emotions. This can make them feel isolated in their own illness. 

This silence can interrupt an important psychological process. Many people facing serious illness move back and forth between hope and fear, living and preparing, fighting and adapting. When dying is not acknowledged, patients may be denied the space to ask questions about what lies ahead, express fear, sadness, anger, or peace, say important things to the people they love, engage in legacy work or life review, and make choices about their care, relationships, or unfinished business.

Coping is about being allowed to be real.

Protection can become a burden

Ironically, silence often shifts the emotional burden onto the patient. Instead of being protected, they become the protector – monitoring their words, hiding tears, reassuring others, and carrying their fears alone.

This emotional labour is exhausting. We can’t deny that dying is hard. While the family and loved ones are saying goodbye to one person, the person with a life-threatening illness, is saying goodbye to everyone and everything.

It’s a strength to open conversations during the last weeks. Protection through silence isn’t a strength, only a way of coping. Open conversation can be about good memories, achievements, regrets, money, death, the funeral, and forgiveness. 

Dr Ira Byock, an advocate for palliative care, refers to the four most important things in life: Please forgive me. I forgive you. I love you. Goodbye. 

What open conversations offer

Talking about dying doesn’t remove hope. Instead, it often changes its shape. Hope may shift from cure to comfort, from length of life to quality of life, from fear to meaning, from control to connection. 

When families allow space for honest conversations, patients often experience relief from emotional isolation and a sense   of greater trust and closeness. But more important, the freedom to live more fully in the time that remains.

These conversations don’t need to happen all at once. They can be gentle, paced, and guided by the person who is ill.

For families: A gentle reframe

Protecting someone doesn’t always mean shielding them from the truth. Sometimes it means walking with them  into it.

You don’t need perfect words or answers. You only need presence. Silence can feel safer, but connection is what truly comforts.

For those who are ill

If you’re the one facing illness and feel surrounded by silence, know this: your thoughts and fears are valid. Wanting to talk about dying doesn’t mean you are giving up. It means you’re human. 

Sometimes it helps to invite the conversation gently:

• There’s something on my mind I’d like to talk about.
• I don’t need fixing; I just need you to listen.
• I want us to be honest with each other.

Breaking the silence, one moment at a time

The silence around dying isn’t a failure of love, it’s often an expression of it. But love can grow when silence softens into shared truth.

Talking about dying doesn’t make it happen sooner. It makes the time that remains more authentic, more connected, and less lonely.

And in that shared honesty, many  families discover something unexpected: not despair, but deep love, courage, and moments of meaning that would otherwise have remained unspoken.

Dr Nelia Drenth is a palliative care social worker in private practice in Pretoria, Gauteng. She presents workshops on psychosocial palliative care and bereavement counselling and has a passion for social work in healthcare.

Header image by Magnific